Optical Glass For Binoculars – What Is ED Glass?

In binoculars and optical instruments, the use of the right glass is crucial to the quality of the produced images. High-quality and specially processed glass prevents light scattering, unwanted reflections and color fringing caused by different refraction of light of different wavelengths.

Which glass do you need for binoculars?

Glass consists of a great percentage of Silicon dioxide. To manipulate the properties of glass for optical applications, additional ingredients such as boron, barium, fluoride, sodium, potassium, calcium, aluminum, lead, and their oxides and compounds are added.

Depending on the quantity and mixture of those ingredients, the resulting optical glass has different properties regarding transmission, refraction, reflection, and absorption.

The glass used in optical instruments

The glass produced for optical lenses and prisms is primarily Crown Glass and Flint Glass. These can have different qualities and optical properties depending on the mix of glass melt ingredients. The designers of binoculars and telescopes combine different glasses with different optical properties to cancel out unwanted aberration of lenses until bright, crisp high-quality images in true color are produced.

Type of glass used in making lenses and prisms

Crown glass is a glass with a high content of potassium oxide (“potash”). It is a hard optical glass with an Abbe number of around 50 to 60. Due to this low refractive index and low dispersion, crown glass is used to produce achromatic lenses.

Flint glass is a very clear and highly transmissible glass, commonly used for lenses and prisms. It is manufactured from potassium and lead-silicates, resulting in a glass with a much higher dispersion and higher index of refraction than crown glass (thus a lower Abbe number). Particularly important are its properties to reduce certain aberrations in combination with crown glass. (Achromat).

BK7 and BaK4 Glass

The prisms in the binoculars are usually made of BK7 or Bak4 glass. Both are types of crown glass, which differ in their optical properties and price.

BK7 glass is a very common Borosilicate crown glass. It is widely used for lenses and prisms in the budget and medium price range.

bk4 shade exit pupil

Bak4Barium crown glass has better optical properties, but is more expensive to manufacture and therefore usually found in high-quality optics and premium binoculars. The higher transmission of BaK4 glass provides better detail resolution and a brighter color-true image.

A simple test can reveal whether BK7 or BaK4 glass is used in the binoculars. Hold the binoculars about an arm’s length away against a bright background and look at the exit pupil. If the exit pupil appears with square, slightly darkened fields at the edge, it is Bk7 glass. If it looks nice round and without dark shades, then it is a BaK 4 glass.

What is ED-Glas?

ED glass (Extra-Low-Dispersion Glass), is a special glass that is that contains calcium-fluoride, it is also known as Fluoride glass.  ED glass is complex in its production and processing and is therefore usually found only in premium binoculars.

Fluoride glass has a very low refractive index, which means that the bending of light and the breaking it up into its constituent colors (dispersion) is less than in a glass with a higher refractive index.

Lenses made of Extra-Low-Dispersion Glass reduce chromatic aberration (color fringing), the result is an exceptionally detailed, true to color and extremely contour sharp and high-contrast image.

High dispersion glass = increased color fringing

Low dispersion glass = reduced color fringing

Image Errors – Aberration in binoculars

Creating perfect binoculars is impossible. Light behaves according to the laws of physics. This causes more or less severe errors in image projection.  However, the optics designer can apply those laws to minimize image errors in binoculars (aberration)  as much as possible, by skillfully combining the properties of the optical components.

Dispersion

Dispersion in a PrismThe term dispersion comes from the Latin word “dispersio” and means “to spread”. In optics, it describes the separation of white light into its constituent colors according to wavelength. Just think of how a rainbow is formed.

When light travels through different media, the speed of light changes. The change in speed is dependent on the medium refractive index as well as on the wavelength of the light.

For example, when passing through a prism or a lens, long-wave red light is refracted less than the short-wave violet light.

Sending white light through a prism demonstrates how light is fanned out into a spectrum, it is divided into its color components. Dispersion of light is also responsible for the red of a sunset or sunrise

A perfect lens would focus all wavelengths into a single focal point. Unfortunately, there is no perfect lens.

Chromatic Aberration – Color Fringing

Chromatic Aberration

Dispersion of light is responsible for chromatic aberration, the appearance of color fringes on high-contrast images (as shown exaggerated in the eagle images further above).

Especially in cheap binoculars, color fringing may occur. Chromatic aberration appears when viewing an object against a high contrasting background. A viewer will then notice bluish edges around the viewed object.

Manufactures of binoculars try to reduce this phenomenon by designing complex optical systems in which errors of different glass’ cancel each other out. This can be done through lens systems combining two or more lenses, such as the Achromatic doublet seen below.

What is an Achromatic Doublet

ApochromatExtra low dispersion glass is used in the objective lens systems of premium binoculars and good birdwatching binoculars, to compensate for the different degrees of refraction of the color components (wavelengths) of a light beam.

An Achromatic doublet is such a lens system. Properties of different glass types reduce the blurred edges and color distortions and the image is much more detailed and color-true.

What is Spherical Aberration?

In cheap binoculars, a decreasing image sharpness towards the edge of the projected images can appear. Depending on the quality of the binoculars, this blur may be strong to barely perceptible.

Spherical Aberration

The reason for this phenomenon known as Spherical Aberration is that the incoming light that passes through a spherical lens ends up focusing at different points after passing through that spherical lens. In other words, light rays that are near the horizontal axis and rays further from the axis are not focused on the same point of the optical axis.

Sperical Aberration
Spherical aberration can cause blurring in the picture and affect resolution and clarity, making it hard to obtain sharp images.  The below images show Spherical Aberration:

Spherical Aberration, reduced sharpness at the image periphery

No Spherical Aberration, Clear High Resolution at the image periphery

This error caused by a spherically curved lens surface can be corrected with the help of aspherical lenses or through lens systems that combine convex and concave lenses to move the foci in different directions.

https://www.edmundoptics.com/resources/application-notes/optics/all-about-aspheric-lenses/

What is lens coating for?

Coating lenses and prisms is essential to improve the image quality of binoculars. Coating the glass refers to thin metal oxide layers that are vapor-deposited on optical glass. The purpose of lens coatings is to minimize reflection thus increasing the light transmission of the optical system. Depending on the metal oxide used, the layer thickness and refractive index of the oxide reflections and aberrations are reduced. In premium binoculars, as many as seven or eight coatings may be applied to cover the entire wavelength of the visible spectrum to achieve the best possible light transmission. Lens coatings greatly determine the quality and the price of binoculars.

Sources:
edmundoptics.com/resources/application-notes/optics/optical-glass/
sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/spherical-aberration
photographylife.com/what-is-chromatic-aberration